Critique of Potebnia in Boris Engelhardt’s works

Critique of Potebnia in Boris Engelhardt’s works
Авторы (текстом)
S.N. Zenkin
Russian State University for the Humanities
Keywords
Potebnia, Engelhardt (Engelgardt), methodology, theory of lan-guage, aesthetic
Abstract

Boris Mikhailovich Engelhardt (ou Engelgardt, 1887–1942) wrote two long articles which were aimed at methodological revision of Alexander Potebnia’s theory in 1920s; they were published only after the author’s demise in 2005. With respect to Potebnia, Engelhardt developed four moves: 1) he localized him on the methodological map of philology (as a representative of the «gnoseological psychologism»; 2) he substituted the Potebnia’s psychological no-tion of «image» by «symbol», which has explicit expression and serves to the com-municative and cognitive aims; 3) in the theory of poetical work, he distinguished the notions of thinking and cognition, which were confounded by Potebnia, and characterized poetry as a self-sufficient and non-cognitive form of thinking; 4) he revised Potebnia’s historical typology of verbal culture and pointed out an increase (and not weakening) of poeticism of language while the latter provides a fund of non-poetic, terminological words.

Bibliography

Boldyrev A. N. Osadnaja zapis': Blokadnyj dnevnik. SPb.: Evropejskij dom, 1998.

Vinogradov V. V. O teorii hudozhestvennoj rechi. M.: Vyssh. shk., 1971.

Voloshinov V. N. Marksizm i filosofija jazyka. L.: Priboj, 1929.

Lévi-StraussK. Strukturnaja antropologija. M.: Nauka, Gl. red. vost. lit., 1983.

Lotman Ju. M. Ob iskusstve. SPb.: Iskusstvo-SPb, 1998.

Potebnia A. A. Estetika i poetika. M.: Iskusstvo, 1976.

Engelhardt B. M. Aleksandr Nikolaevich Veselovskij. Pg.: Kolos, 1924.

Engelhardt B. M. Formal'nyj metod v istorii literatury. L.: Academia, 1927 // Engelhardt B. M. Izbrsnnye trudy / Pod red. A. B. Muratova. SPb.: Izd-vo SPbGU, 1995.

Engelhardt B. M. Fenomenologija i teorija slovesnosti / Sost., predisl., poslesl., nauch. komment. A. B. Muratova. M.: Novoe lit. obozrenie, 2005.

Bibliographic reference
S.N. Zenkin Critique of Potebnia in Boris Engelhardt’s works // Критика и семиотика. 2014. № 20. Pp. 138–148.